1985 Hasbro My Little Pony Heartthrob

BRAND
YEAR 1985
MODEL TBA
POWER
CATEGORY
Toys and Hobbies
Toys and Hobbies
MINT VALUE Expensive ($200-$300)
RATING TBA

Running this archive is expensive! To help pay these bills, I use the eBay Partner Network, so if you click on an eBay link and buy, I earn a small commission at no cost to you. 

?
out of 5
Review
We are busy researching and writing this article on the 1985 Hasbro My Little Pony Heartthrob. If you have anything to contribute, please use the comments at the bottom of the page.

VALUE / PRICE HISTORY

Average Price

$12.99

Highest Price

$215.00

Date Price Condition Type Title
2025-08-20 $14.99 Used Auction Vintage My Little Pony Heart Throb Stickles Amtoy 1985 Hasbro Rare E3
2025-08-20 $24.87 Used Buy Vintage My Little Pony MLP G1 Candy Cane Ponies Mint Dreams 1985 Hasbro
2025-08-20 $44.99 Used Buy Vintage G1 1985 My Little Pony Baby Buggy With Baby Cuddles Near Complete Set
Average price is based on 15 recorded sales (max 10 shown).
Prices in USD. While all care is taken, there is no guarantee on accuracy of this data.
This is a draft article on the 1985 Hasbro My Little Pony Heartthrob that is still being written. This can include researching hard to find items, buying them, speaking with owners, etc. If you’d like to contribute or correct any details, please use the Comments Box below or contact me. Until then, enjoy what’s here, and keep in mind it’s a work in progress. Thank you.

ITEM REVIEW

The My Little Pony Heartthrob was a Pegasus pony, which was manufactured by Hasbro and subsequently released in 1985.

Background

My Little Pony Heartthrob finds its roots in the broader My Little Pony (MLP) franchise, which was first introduced by Hasbro in 1982—and this line of toys rapidly became a staple in the toy industry, especially throughout the 1980s and 1990s, captivating children with its vibrant colors and imaginative characters. Heartthrob emerged in the second wave of the first generation (G1) of My Little Pony toys, debuting in the mid-1980s.

Heartthrob is a distinct character within the MLP universe, recognized for her pink body, blue eyes, and pink mane. Her symbol, or “cutie mark,” is three pink hearts with white wings—which aligns with her character’s romantic and dreamy personality. This design choice reflects the toy line’s emphasis on unique and easily recognizable characters that appeal to young children.

The creation of Heartthrob and other G1 ponies was a part of Hasbro’s strategy to capitalize on the growing popularity of collectible toys—each pony was designed with a unique persona, encouraging kids to collect and engage in imaginative play. Heartthrob’s character was particularly targeted at children who enjoyed fantasy and romance-themed narratives.

Features

The My Little Pony toys, including Heartthrob, were celebrated for their innovative features at the time—these toys were made from durable plastic with a soft, brushable mane and tail, which allowed for a unique play experience. The ability to style the ponies’ hair was one of the main attractions, providing children with the opportunity to express creativity.

Heartthrob’s design also included teh distinct pose—known as the “Surprise Pose”—which added to her charm. The pose featured her standing with an expressive stance, suggesting movement and liveliness. Her cutie mark, consisting of three pink hearts with wings, covered a significant portion of her flank, making her easily identifiable among the other ponies from the series.

Another interesting facet of the G1 My Little Ponies was their packaging. Each toy came with a backcard story, providing a narrative context for the character. Heartthrob’s story often involved themes of love and friendship, which were consistent with her character’s persona and the overarching themes of the MLP universe.

Popularity and Legacy

Heartthrob, like many of her contemporaries, enjoyed considerable popularity during the peak of the My Little Pony franchise— the character’s romantic and endearing nature appealed to children and helped solidify her place in the MLP pantheon. The 1980s and 1990s were a golden era for the franchise, with the toys being highly sought after by young collectors.

Despite not being a central figure in the later generations of My Little Pony, Heartthrob maintains a legacy through nostalgia and the enduring appeal of the original MLP series. The character has appeared in various forms, including animated series and comics, although these appearances have been more limited compared to other main characters.

Collectors and fans of the original My Little Pony toys continue to hold Heartthrob in high esteem. Her unique design and the sentimental value attached to the G1 series contribute to her lasting legacy in the world of collectible toys.

Advertisements / Commercials

Check out this vintage TV commercial for the 1985 Hasbro My Little Pony Heartthrob where various My Little Pony toys are shown. The commercial includes the My Little Pony Paradise Estate playset, with multiple rooms for ponies to live in. It also shows the My Little Pony Waterfall, where children can shampoo their pony’s hair. Additionally, the commercial features other ponies like the Sea Ponies and Sparkle Ponies, and mentions the Sunday Best Ponies with ice cream-themed scents.

Availability and Collectability

Today, Heartthrob is considered a highly collectible item, especially among enthusiasts of the original My Little Pony series. The toy’s condition, rarity, and completeness (including original packaging and accessories) significantly impact its value in the secondary market. Collectors often seek out Heartthrob for its nostalgic value and as part of completing their G1 collections.

The availability of Heartthrob varies, with some versions being more common than others—in particular, the “So Soft” version of Heartthrob, which features a flocked texture, is one of the variations that collectors find particularly appealing. This version was released in Year Four (1985-1986) and is noted for its distinctive texture and light blue ribbon accessory.

Online marketplaces such as eBay and specialty collector sites are common venues where Heartthrob and other vintage My Little Pony toys are bought and sold. Prices can vary widely based on the toy’s condition and rarity, with some listings reaching several hundred dollars for well-preserved examples.

Like it? Then you might also like...

DISCUSSION

Leave the first comment

Information here is to the best of my knowledge at the time of writing, and is frequently updated and improved as I learn more. Contact Me for Feedback or Corrections. Gimme80s.com is not responsible for inaccurate information or commentary, media, or links posted by 3rd parties.